Post Rebuttal ICML Average Scores? [D]

I have an average of 3.5. One of the reviewer gave us a 2 by bringing up a new issue he hadn’t mentioned in his initial review, taking that from another reviewer’s concerns. The reviewer he took it from already mentioned that it isn’t an actual issue too.

Paper Co-Pilot is driving me crazy, apparently 4.2 is just the top 40% of papers according to it.