[R] CVPR first submission, need advice
Helllo!
As everyone knows, cvpr reviews are out, I got 3 reviews 4(confidence 3), 4(confidence 3), 4(confidence 4).
The first reviewer said he can improve if i provided more details about that, and a chance in the manuscript to move stuff from supplementary to the main paper. Second reviewer said he also have some questions but without concrete promises to upgrade. The 3rd review with most confidence did not specifct any requirement or promise to raise, but also had some things like uncertanity, and general questions in the weakness.
My questions are :-
-
For the experienced authours in cvpr, how good are my chances?
-
As far as I know I can’t provide anything more than 1 rebuttal page, is it fair to include new experiements with promises to include it in camera ready? Or it is not allowed?
-
Any idea what is the likelihood of being improved? And for the worst case to keep scores as they are, can the paper still be accepted?
-
What are the best practises for rebuttal? I want to try to cover as much as possible of the questions but it is not that easy I think, since everything has to fit in 1 page.
Any input from you will be really appreciated! This is basically the paper of my past year of really a lot of work, and all my hopes are to get it accepted, as I really believe it deserves that.
Thanks in advance!
submitted by /u/Internal_Seaweed_844
[link] [comments]