Combining in-shuffles and out-shuffles
A few days ago I wrote two posts about perfect shuffles. Once you’ve cut a deck of cards in half, an in-shuffle lets a card from the top half fall first, and an out-shuffle lets a card from the bottom half fall first.
Suppose we have a deck of 52 cards. We said in the earlier posts that the order of an in-shuffle I is 52. That is, after 52 in-shuffles, a deck returns to its initial order. And the order of an out-shuffle O is 8.
We can think of I and O as generators of subgroups of order 52 and 8 respectively in the group S of all permutations of 52 cards. I was curious when I wrote the earlier posts how large the group generated by I and O together would be. Is it possible to reach all 52! permutations of the deck by some combination of applying I and O? If not, how many permutations can be generated?
I’ve since found the answer in [1] in a theorem by Diaconis, Graham, and Kantor. I don’t know who Kantor is, but it’s no surprise that a theorem on card shuffles would come from Persi Diaconis and Ron Graham. The theorem covers the case for decks of size N = 2n, which branches into different results depending on the size of n and the value of n mod 4.
For N = 52, the group generated by I and O has
26! × 226
elements.
On the one hand, that’s a big number, approximately 2.7 × 1034. On the other hand, it’s quite small compared to 52! = 8 × 1067. So while there are a lot of permutations reachable by a combination of in-shuffles and out-shuffles, your chances of selecting such a permutation from the set of all such permutations is vanishingly small.
To put it yet another way, the number of arrangements is on the order of the square root of 52!, a big number, but not big relative to 52!. (Does this pattern
√52! ≈ 26! × 226
generalize? See the next post.)
Not only does the theorem of Diaconis et al give the order of the group, it gives the group itself: the group of permutations generated by I and O is isomorphic to the group of symmetries of a 26-dimensional octahedron.
[1] S. Brent Morris. Magic Tricks, Card Shuffling and Dynamic Computer Memories. MAA 1998.
The post Combining in-shuffles and out-shuffles first appeared on John D. Cook.
